Demonstrate the use of a microwave dry substance transducer for controlling high grade boilings
Australian sugar factories currently use massecuite conductivity to control the feed rate of syrup and molasses to pans. Conductivity control is inexpensive and works well, although it does require close attention from pan operators since the conductivity value is affected by variations in the impurity composition in the cane supply.
Microwave transducers to measure massecuite dry substance (DS) are now being used in several overseas refineries and factories for control of the massecuite condition in pans. In SMRP 2023/202 it was shown that the Berthold microwave transducer provided a reliable measure of the massecuite DS in an A massecuite pan at Farleigh Mill (ASSCT paper 2024). During this project, a correlation was established with reasonable accuracy between the transducer DS output and factory samples. However, it was not possible to demonstrate the effectiveness of the DS transducer for control of the pan’s operation prior to the finish of the season. Challenges with the control parameters of the program were determined and could not be solved as the accurate correlation was only established near the end of the season.
The overall aim of this project is to demonstrate the use of a microwave dry substance transducer for controlling high grade boilings to a pre-defined DS profile as described by Broadfoot and Fraga (ASSCT paper 2023). Improved control will result in cost reduction due to less manual interaction than currently required with conductivity control. An absolute measure of massecuite concentration, is an important first step to reducing the manning requirements on the pan stage in Australian factories.
• Determine the accuracy of the calibration developed during the 2023 season against massecuite dry substance values during different periods of the 2024 season (to assess the effects of changed cane supply conditions). The instrument Berthold DS transducer is installed in Pan 9 at Farleigh Mill (190 t) and boils A massecuite and high-grade seed. If needed, an improved calibration will be developed. The SMRP determined an accuracy of ±0.2 DS is required (corresponding to a deviation in supersaturation of ±0.03).
• Evaluate the pan’s performance when using the DS transducer signal to control the pan to a pre-set DS profile, fitting the DS profile based on experience from the SMRP and comparing to the profile determined by Broadfoot and Fraga (2023 ASSCT).
• Compare with the effectiveness for pan control of using conductivity or dry substance, including an assessment of the need for manual intervention by operators. Prepare report and incorporate recommendations for other factories to implement pan control using microwave DS transducers.
Objectives
• Determine the accuracy of the calibration developed during the 2023 season against massecuite dry substance values during different periods of the 2024 season (to assess the effects of changed cane supply conditions). The instrument Berthold DS transducer is installed in Pan 9 at Farleigh Mill (190 t) and boils A massecuite and high-grade seed. If needed, an improved calibration will be developed. The SMRP determined an accuracy of ±0.2 DS is required (corresponding to a deviation in supersaturation of ±0.03).
• Evaluate the pan’s performance when using the DS transducer signal to control the pan to a pre-set DS profile, fitting the DS profile based on experience from the SMRP and comparing to the profile determined by Broadfoot and Fraga (2023 ASSCT).
• Compare with the effectiveness for pan control of using conductivity or dry substance, including an assessment of the need for manual intervention by operators. Prepare report and incorporate recommendations for other factories to implement pan control using microwave DS transducers.

Expected Outputs
The main outputs from the project are:
•Knowledge of the pan’s performance when using the DS transducer signal to control it to a pre-determined massecuite dry substance profile as a comparison with the use of conductivity, including an assessment of the need for manual intervention by operators.
The information from the project will be available to assist mills to make decisions regarding the change from the use of conductivity to massecuite dry substance for pan control in Australian factories.
The outputs from this project will be available to the milling industry prior to the 2025 season. It is feasible that other mills could purchase and install the microwave transducer before the completion of the 2025 season.
No third parties (other than one of the instrument suppliers) will be required to assist mills in implementing the massecuite DS control.
Expected Outcomes
It must be recognised that SRA SMRP 2023/202 and this project are first steps to transforming operations on Australian pan stages to largely de-manned operations. The Australian sugar milling industry has advised SRA that increased automation is a high priority. There are two main factors necessitating this change:
• High turnover of staff and difficulty recruiting suitable operational staff. Consequently, the experience-based knowledge of operational staff, in general, is reducing.
• Australian factories need to cut costs to remain competitive.
These changes need to be made while maintaining reliability, productivity, sucrose recovery and quality. Specifically for this project, the main benefits that should result if massecuite DS measurement proves to be suitable for tighter control of individual pans are greater consistency in the production of well exhausted massecuites, potentially shorter cycle times, reduced incidence of forming fine grain and much reduced manual input from pan stage operators. The massecuite DS measurement should prove to be a process variable that is less impacted by changes in cane supply as is currently the case with conductivity. A follow-on project is required to install massecuite DS transducers onto different pans in the industry (B and C massecuite pans, unstirred pans) and operate them to pre-set massecuite DS profiles in fully automated control. This project would only be undertaken if the proposed SMRP investigation demonstrates the reliability and accuracy of the massecuite DS transducer under the proposed range of circumstances.
The outputs of this project are applicable for use in all Australian mills to enhance pan control and advance the competitiveness of Australian factories in the international market.
CHIEF INVESTIGATOR: Bryan Lavarack
END DATE: 01/07/2025




